Posted by Shaykh on Apr 2, 2010 in Featured, Menstruation, Taharah | 2 comments
Question:
Can women go to a mosque that used to be a church building a long time ago,
whilst menstruating?
Thanks
Answer:
يحرم على المرأة دخول المسجد فى حالة الحيض وإن كان ذلك المسجد من أصل الكنيسة لأن الحكم تبدل بتبدل الماهية فصارت الكنيسة الآن فى حكم المسجد بعد جعلها ونيتها مسجدا والامور بمقاصدها ..
It is prohibited for a woman to enter a masjid (mosque) while menstruating, even though, the masjid (mosque) was originally a church.
This is because the hukm (law) of something changes by the change of its nature. So the church now takes the ruling of a masjid after it was made to be a masjid and because it is intended to be a masjid, and matters are judged based upon what is intended, (al-Ashbah: 38).
والله أعلم وعلمه أتم
Answered by:
Al-Ustadh Abdul Fattah al-Shāfiʿī
Kubang Bujuk, Malaysia
Salam,
What is al-Ashbah:38? Is this a referall to a Qur’anic verse or a fiqh book?
Greetings,
Harun
Dear Harun,
Al-Ashbah is one of the Shafi’ie Fiqh Methodology Manuals written by the renowned polymath specialist scholar, Imam Jalaluddin As-Suyuti, the full name of the book is Al-Ashbah Wan-Naza’ir